Back to blog

AI-Enabled Recruiter vs AI Recruiter: Key Differences

In this article

Matthijs Metzemaekers
Co-founder, Carv
A visionary tech entrepreneur with over a decade of experience.

While AI isn't here to steal your job, it's undeniably transforming the recruitment landscape at an astonishing speed, and to be ready for the future of recruitment, we need to start understanding the implications today.

So let's shed some light on the two major trends emerging: AI-enabled recruiters and AI recruiters. These might sound alike, but the key differences are crucial to understanding the future of your profession.

Let’s start with some definitions, to understand how these concepts compare.

AI recruiter vs AI-enabled recruiter: Definitions

An AI-enabled recruiter refers to a human recruiter who harnesses AI tools and technologies to augment their recruitment efforts.

These professionals employ AI-powered tools to automate repetitive tasks like resume screening and candidate sourcing, gaining valuable insights into candidate data. Their engagement extends to incorporating artificial intelligence tools, such as chatbots and generic AI solutions like ChatGPT or Gemini, within what we term as AI-assisted workflows.

In comparison to talent acquisition professionals not integrating AI into their daily routines, AI-enabled recruiters enjoy heightened autonomy and possess broader knowledge. This is facilitated by AI, allowing them to surpass traditional skill limitations and access extensive information across domains.

Furthermore, AI-enabled recruiters tap into the creative capabilities of AI systems, enhancing their innovative thinking and problem-solving skills on demand. The democratization of creativity through gen AI ensures that every recruiter, regardless of their innate creative abilities, can meaningfully contribute to creative initiatives and ideation processes.

Beyond creativity, AI-enabled recruiters achieve remarkable efficiency by leveraging AI's automation and data analysis capabilities. This enables streamlined workflows, identification of bottlenecks, and optimization of resource allocation, resulting in substantial gains in productivity.

While AI-enabled recruitment is promising, the impact of AI on the TA landscape is poised to advance further, with autonomous hiring led by AI recruiters as the end state.

So what are AI recruiters?

An AI recruiter is a fully automated system that employs artificial intelligence to perform recruitment tasks such as screening resumes, scheduling interviews, and even conducting initial interviews with candidates.

AI recruiters or workmates form the cornerstone of autonomous recruitment. Although designed to seamlessly collaborate with human counterparts, they operate independently, requiring minimal to no human intervention.

Typically utilized by organizations with high-volume recruitment needs, such as staffing agencies or in-house recruitment teams in industries focused on volume hiring, AI recruitment tools offer benefits to talent acquisition professionals of all sizes and industries due to their versatile use cases.

In summary, an AI recruiter is a fully automated system that independently performs recruitment tasks, while an AI-enabled recruiter is a human talent acquisition professional who uses AI tools to expedite the hiring process and enhance its effectiveness.

Note: If these concepts are new to you, take some moments to check our previous articles on the AI-enabled employee, AI workmates, and human-AI synergy to gain a better understanding of how AI is reshaping the workplace.

Now that the distinction between the two concepts is clear, let's delve into the strengths and limitations of both to understand the role each plays in the future of recruitment. This comparative view will help you choose the right approach moving forward.

Demystifying the dynamics of recruiter-AI collaboration

Before we dive into the details of how recruiters and artificial intelligence can work together, let's cut through the panic and hype surrounding AI in the workplace.

In both scenarios – AI-assisted and AI-led hiring – human recruiters continue to play a crucial role in the recruitment process. They use their expertise for final hiring decisions, relationship building with candidates and stakeholders, and ensuring ethical practices.

Thus, rather than an "either-or" approach, the future of recruitment likely holds a synergy between humans and AI, leveraging each other's strengths for effective, efficient, and fair hiring practices.

Where AI recruiters shine

As mentioned earlier, AI recruiters represent independent AI systems working alongside talent acquisition professionals, undertaking tasks that humans either shouldn't dedicate time to or are less equipped for.

Functioning as highly intelligent counterparts to human recruiters, AI recruiters serve as digital assistants that actively collaborate in real time. They streamline processes, automate tasks, and act as valuable brainstorming partners.

Equipped with virtually infinite memory, AI recruiters can access and store vast amounts of information, irrespective of format, language, or media type. They remain consistently up-to-date with the latest regulations and rules across various domains.

Moreover, AI recruiters exhibit infinite execution power, excelling in repetitive tasks and seamlessly running workflows 24/7. They can be programmed to perform diverse activities, from extensive research to complex analyses, with the quality of their output optimized through context enrichment and feedback.

In addition to these strengths, AI recruiters effortlessly communicate across languages, facilitating global recruitment for organizations lacking these skills in-house. Whether written, text-based, or video, AI workmates interpret unstructured information and respond with precision, transforming linguistic diversity into a workplace strength.

Lastly, AI hiring agents demonstrate infinite learning ability, adapting to evolving technologies and learning from every interaction. Unhindered by cognitive saturation or fatigue, they continually enhance problem-solving skills, decision-making processes, and overall efficacy. In essence, AI workmates redefine workplace dynamics, offering unparalleled capabilities that contribute to a more efficient, adaptive, and innovative work environment.

While AI recruiters are designed to augment human recruiters and free up their time for more strategic aspects, it's crucial to acknowledge their limitations. AI tools should be viewed as complements, not replacements for human skills.

Where humans remain essential

The emergence of AI-enabled recruiters has sparked debates on the potential displacement of human roles. However, as mentioned earlier, AI workmates, despite their remarkable abilities, have limitations.

Rather than succumbing to the fear of the unknown, let's explore collaborative possibilities and focus on specific areas where humans will continue to maintain control within the recruitment process.

AI recruiters may struggle in situations requiring nuanced understanding of human communication or contextual intricacies. Although gen AI technology can understand human language and context, it lacks human intuition and the ability to "read the room".

Despite being programmable to appear sociable, AI workmates lack the ability to read social cues and face challenges in relationship-building, lacking a memory of past interactions unless explicitly instructed. Additionally, they lack inherent understanding of social sensitivities.

For this reason, we believe human recruiters will continue to lead, handling real-time face-to-face communication with candidates and stakeholders, while AI counterparts focus on written communication - pre-interview engagement or follow-up tasks. AI workmates depend on human intervention or retraining to adjust their behavior, and the quality of their output hinges on the quality of input.

Artificial intelligence systems fall short in strategic thinking compared to humans. They are less adept at business goal setting, risk evaluation, and long-term strategic planning, often unable to identify the best course of action in complex situations. Although they can assist in collecting and interpreting information, connecting the dots to form a coherent recruitment strategy aligned with business goals is likely to remain a human task.

Finally, while AI recruiting agents demonstrate impressive learning capabilities, their decision-making power is confined. AI cannot autonomously decide what skills to learn, what tools to use, or how to proceed from step A to step B.

In summary, even in AI-led recruitment, human recruiters will continue to leverage their strengths:

  • Candidate relationship building: Human recruiters excel at building rapport and trust with job applicants, aspects that are crucial for a good candidate experience and successful recruitment. AI can handle the initial written communication through, engaging with job seekers through talent pools or social media platforms, to find the right candidates.
  • Soft skills assessment: AI can identify skills but lacks the ability to evaluate soft skills like communication and teamwork, requiring human judgment. Thus, although artificial intelligence can help in creating candidate profiles and matching applicants with open positions based on job requirements, the final hiring decision should be made by human recruiters.
  • Creative problem-solving: While AI is great in automating time-consuming tasks, human adaptability and problem-solving skills shine when unexpected challenges arise, a realm where AI's rigid algorithms may stumble.
  • Ethical evaluations: Given how new the use of AI in hiring is, human oversight is needed to ensure ethical and fair recruitment practices.

As you can see, even in AI-powered recruiting, human involvement remains essential in relationship-building, decision-making, and strategic planning, positioning AI workmates as tools that augment human capabilities rather than replace them.

With this out of the way, let's delve into what hiring teams can expect from human-AI synergy.

What hiring teams can expect from human-AI collaboration

Currently grappling with an AI adoption gap, an increasing number of companies are recognizing the advantages of artificial intelligence and exploring ways to integrate it into their daily operations.

To initiate this transformation, companies can start by incorporating AI into specific recruitment tasks, progressing from an AI-enabled workforce to fully autonomous recruitment.

Here are some benefits that AI can bring to recruiting teams:

  • Speed and efficiency: AI algorithms effortlessly sift through talent pools, rapidly identifying top talent and evaluating thousands of resumes within seconds. This streamlines the shortlisting process and reduces time-to-hire, while allowing human recruiters to focus on deeper engagement with potential candidates.
  • Automation of repetitive recruitment tasks: AI recruiters handle repetitive activities like summarizing intake calls into detailed job descriptions, converting candidate interviews into profiles, and matching qualified candidates with job openings. They can even post vacancies on job boards and generate motivation letters for hiring managers.
  • 24/7 availability: Unlike human recruiters, AI recruitment systems operate tirelessly, creating job postings, screening candidates, and providing automatic updates around the clock. This global availability proves particularly valuable for organizations engaged in international recruitment efforts.
  • Global reach: AI recruiting software efficiently searches for talent across vast geographical regions and diverse candidate pools, identifying the best candidates for various roles. In the case of staffing agencies, it can match job seekers with multiple clients.
  • Adaptability and insights: Recruiting solutions powered by AI algorithms continuously learn and evolve based on data, leading to improved decision-making and deeper insights into talent pools over time. This can help recruitment and HR teams improve quality of hire and retention rates.
  • Reduced bias: AI recruiting platforms, relying on objective data points, combat unconscious bias in resume screening, video interviewing, and candidate profiling. This results in fairer and more diverse candidate pools.
  • Reduced costs: AI recruiting technology automates routine talent acquisition processes, reducing labor costs and enhancing overall efficiency.

These benefits are applicable in both AI-driven hiring and AI-assisted recruitment scenarios. However, a technology-first approach, where AI takes the lead with human oversight and intervention as needed, is likely to have a more profound impact.

The challenge now is to determine the best approach for your specific use case. Where should you start?

Choosing the right path to get started

The choice between AI-enabled and AI recruiters hinges on several factors, including your company size, budget constraints, specific recruitment needs, and risk tolerance.

To achieve an optimal balance, you might consider adopting a hybrid approach that combines your human expertise with AI capabilities, and build from there.

Effective entry points

Start with specific AI tools for tasks like resume screening or candidate outreach. This will serve as effective entry points for you and your team, enabling TA colleagues to gain familiarity with AI technology and witness its impact on specific aspects of your workflows.

Gradual integration and incremental transformation

You need not undertake a complete system overhaul overnight. Instead, initiate a phased approach, starting small and gradually integrating AI tools into your processes. This allows you to learn, adapt, and scale AI adoption at a pace aligned with your comfort and readiness.

Embark on a journey of gradual integration, iterating on your current tech stack and ways of working. Introduce an AI recruiting platform next to your applicant tracking system for targeted tasks and progressively expand its role as your confidence in the technology grows.

This step-by-step approach can ensure a smoother transition and better alignment with your organizational needs, minimizing disruptions to your recruitment operations.

Autonomous recruitment as the end goal

While starting small is crucial, the ultimate goal is autonomous recruitment. Envision AI recruiters gradually taking on more responsibilities independently, allowing you to shift your focus toward strategic decision-making, relationship-building, and other high-value tasks.

In summary, the journey toward incorporating AI into your recruitment processes is not an all-or-nothing endeavor. By taking measured steps, your organization can harness the benefits of AI while respecting your unique requirements and pace of adaptation.

Over to you

As the recruitment landscape undergoes a transformative phase, the choice between adopting AI-enabled recruiters and AI recruiters becomes pivotal.

Our belief is that the future of recruitment lies in collaboration, not competition, between humans and AI, with AI recruiters augmenting rather than replacing their human counterparts.

By teaming up, recruiters and AI can create a dynamic and efficient workplace environment, where work gets done more effectively, and talent acquisition teams have more time and space for creative work, relationship building, and strategic thinking.

If you’d like to experience this recruiter-AI synergy firsthand, you can get started today by teaming up with your Carv AI recruiter.

AI-Powered Recruitment

Cut Admin, Boost Hiring
with Carv

Carv is AI purpose-built to take over admin tasks related to intake calls & interviews.